arab niggas come in

Von

2022 is the year of the Somali
Wadani
Joined
Jan 13, 2019
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
3,756
the basic argument groups in two camps that Arab is a cultural identity and since Somalia has have massive influences from Yemen the original Arab state, Somalia is as Arab as Amazigh Morocco or Coptic Egypt. The second camp is Somalia's clan structure based on the fact that Samaale the father of the Somali people for which it named was a Yemeni. So logically Samaale being Arab would mean his children the Somali people would be Arab.

Most Arabs are genetically as Arab as Somalis are which is to say no much so if they are considered Arab why not Somalis. Since Arabs assume Somalis are mixed Arab people they might as will formalise it.

Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk :gelle:
 

prof chomp

tito fanboy
Wadani
Qaxooti
Joined
Sep 12, 2021
Messages
2,088
Reaction score
2,928
the basic argument groups in two camps that Arab is a cultural identity and since Somalia has have massive influences from Yemen the original Arab state, Somalia is as Arab as Amazigh Morocco or Coptic Egypt. The second camp is Somalia's clan structure based on the fact that Samaale the father of the Somali people for which it named was a Yemeni. So logically Samaale being Arab would mean his children the Somali people would be Arab.

Most Arabs are genetically as Arab as Somalis are which is to say no much so if they are considered Arab why not Somalis. Since Arabs assume Somalis are mixed Arab people they might as will formalise it.

Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk :gelle:
fuck it you have convinced me we are Arab lets gozxa89lvjn36iJL6X8vn4I07w9Sdhjag56V455DaCxKU.jpg
 

Gurage

Habesha supremacist
Wadani
Joined
Jul 30, 2020
Messages
2,233
Reaction score
3,482
the basic argument groups in two camps that Arab is a cultural identity and since Somalia has have massive influences from Yemen the original Arab state, Somalia is as Arab as Amazigh Morocco or Coptic Egypt. The second camp is Somalia's clan structure based on the fact that Samaale the father of the Somali people for which it named was a Yemeni. So logically Samaale being Arab would mean his children the Somali people would be Arab.

Most Arabs are genetically as Arab as Somalis are which is to say no much so if they are considered Arab why not Somalis. Since Arabs assume Somalis are mixed Arab people they might as will formalise it.

Thank you for listening to my Ted Talk :gelle:
But those countries such as the maghreb regions have a higher level of arabisation by far, Arabic is the first official language and the language which the vast majority of the population speak, this isn't the case with somalis where about 15% speak arabic to a decent level.

The arabs left a much bigger genetic imprint on the levant, egypt and maghreb than in Somalia. Many of them have authentic arab lineages unlike somalis and in DNA tests they usually record higher arab % than somalis.

Also the Yemenis are not the original arabs, there is large evidence than arabic originated in the northern part of the arabian peninsula such as Northern Saudi, Jordan and the Syrian desert. Yemenis are south semitic and south semitic languages has a strong cushitic substratum that's not found in arabic.
 

Von

2022 is the year of the Somali
Wadani
Joined
Jan 13, 2019
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
3,756
fuck it you have convinced me we are Arab lets goView attachment 42871
Am not saying we are Arab just that they have valid claims as nation:biixi:
But those countries such as the maghreb regions have a higher level of arabisation by far, Arabic is the first official language and the language which the vast majority of the population speak, this isn't the case with somalis where about 15% speak arabic to a decent level.

The arabs left a much bigger genetic imprint on the levant, egypt and maghreb than in Somalia. Many of them have authentic arab lineages unlike somalis and in DNA tests they usually record higher arab % than somalis.

Also the Yemenis are not the original arabs, there is large evidence than arabic originated in the northern part of the arabian peninsula such as Northern Saudi, Jordan and the Syrian desert. Yemenis are south semitic and south semitic languages has a strong cushitic substratum that's not found in arabic.
I am to say Sudan, Arabised Cushitic peoples, Question for you is if Somalis were to adopt Arabic like North Africa and Sudan did would that make them Arab, since Arab is more of cultural thing just by looking at Sudan?
 

رئيس الهود

CCM Iyo UCID Activist|Halwa,Bin Harti,Hali ✨
Wadani
Joined
May 5, 2021
Messages
6,687
Reaction score
9,400
Am not saying we are Arab just that they have valid claims:biixi:

I am to say Sudan, Arabised Cushitic peoples, Question for you is if Somalis were to adopt Arabic like North Africa and Sudan did would that make them Arab, since Arab is more of cultural thing just by looking at Sudan?
Somalis have a reputation for speaking eloquent arabic :cheers:
 

Von

2022 is the year of the Somali
Wadani
Joined
Jan 13, 2019
Messages
3,387
Reaction score
3,756
Somalis have a reputation for speaking eloquent arabic :cheers:
Well don't Somalis choose to speak colloquial Yemeni, not sure what standing that has in the Arab world.

Most Arabs assume I speak Arabic or complain when I don't, am learning the language so Ill see first hand how Arab they will view me:hmok:
 

Gurage

Habesha supremacist
Wadani
Joined
Jul 30, 2020
Messages
2,233
Reaction score
3,482
Am not saying we are Arab just that they have valid claims as nation:biixi:

I am to say Sudan, Arabised Cushitic peoples, Question for you is if Somalis were to adopt Arabic like North Africa and Sudan did would that make them Arab, since Arab is more of cultural thing just by looking at Sudan?
Sure, I consider arab to be more of a cultural and linguistic label than a genetic one.
 
Top